X-Men #5 and 6, published just before Lockdown—and therefore at the tail-end of the Before Times—were the two issues of Hickman’s run that each most clearly prefaced a mystery whose suspense was left to hang for a long time, with the mystery of the mutants in the Vault having been recently and only partially resolved (of course), in X-Men #18-19, and with the mystery of Mystique’s scheme apparently now in payoff mode with the Inferno miniseries. In the Dawn of X, it seemed likely that these and the HOX/POX mysteries—which is obviously where the Destiny plot thread started—would all come crashing down simultaneously when the time came. And they still might, but these days, it seems likelier that these early story seeds will each develop further and resolve at least somewhat on their own and with hopefully more decompression, perhaps aided by a more adroitly staggered publication schedule. Although each of these issues is a teaser and no longer appears to offer any clues to the near future, they still read well and look gorgeous. [Read more…] about (Re)Read Hickman’s X-Men: The City and the Mask – X-Men #5 & #6
(Re)Read Hickman’s X-Men: All Too Worldly – Marauders #2-6
Really, the superficially cynical maneuverings of these worldly aristos are potentially as compelling as those happening in the mysteriously remade Otherworld. Yet while I’ve enjoyed Marauders, its overall execution is flawed in ways quite different from Excalibur’s challenges. Indeed, it’s been the least consistent ongoing, both in terms of direction and quality. But throughout, we’ve certainly gotten a better-than-average series, and dear daddy Duggan shows he’s still got his finger on the pulse of the present. That doesn’t mean it’s not quite literally all over the map!
Related:
[Read more…] about (Re)Read Hickman’s X-Men: All Too Worldly – Marauders #2-6
(Re)Read Hickman’s X-Men: Apocalypse, Now – Excalibur #1-6 Pt. 3
III. #3: “Three Covenants”
You could say Apocalypse and Rictor forge a covenant in this issue, but I’m not sure what the other two are! Maybe another one is Betsy’s agreement with the Queen? Pretty silly to call that a covenant, especially given how blandly it’s presented. (Is it supposed to read so silly?)
Related:
[Read more…] about (Re)Read Hickman’s X-Men: Apocalypse, Now – Excalibur #1-6 Pt. 3
(Re)Read Hickman’s X-Men: Otherworldly Machinations – Excalibur #1-6 Pt. 2
Excalibur will possibly end before it reaches issue #30—although that seems crazy with how much material Tini Howard and Marcus To have introduced, enough for a whole franchise! An entire comic company could be launched from all the elements of their Otherworldly worldbuilding—and X-office contributions, generally. So hopefully, Marvel backs off a bit on its recent kneejerk habit of just rebooting everything without strong in-universe reasons or respect to fans of titles whose stories are never resolved!
That said, this series hasn’t been without its flaws, and its first six issues are its weakest. They still contain much of interest and lay diverse seeds of potential for future storytelling—besides the fact the art is beautiful.
But if the series were to end, it would be a real shame—avoidable if it relaunches with the same creators under a title like Captain Britain and Her Majesty’s Mutants or something. (I’m not a fan of the word “witchbreed,” which is meant to be pejorative anyway; neither is it very compelling.) It’s clear to anyone following Excalibur that the creative team is just getting started with the epic they obviously want to give us. Although that is a bit strange to say after 23 issues!
Related:
[Read more…] about (Re)Read Hickman’s X-Men: Otherworldly Machinations – Excalibur #1-6 Pt. 2
(Re)Read Hickman’s X-Men Era: Disparate Seeds of Stories Yet to Come
X-Men #2-4 by Hickman & Leinil Francis Yu!
4
3
2
What was with this series? It seemed almost every issue tackled a nearly wholly unrelated story setup, related only by way of Krakoa.
I don’t quite believe that, but it is a very common criticism of Hickman’s X-Men, whose hallowed name inevitably set up fan expectations of what the franchise’s flagship title is supposed to look and feel like. Unsurprisingly, Hickman upset what was expected—how X-Men-like after all!
But that doesn’t mean there isn’t plenty to critique here. And yet there’s still much more to praise.
Related:
[Read more…] about (Re)Read Hickman’s X-Men Era: Disparate Seeds of Stories Yet to Come